Progressives against Civil Rights

By Charles Love

A new generation of “antiracist” intellectuals and activists is rewriting rules, canceling nonconformists, and making a grand attempt to rid America of what they consider its systemic racism. With the support of academia, media, and many major corporations, they seem well positioned to achieve their goals. They even have support in in the White House, as President Joe Biden stated in a press conference last month that he will make “racial equity” a priority for the “whole of government.” Yet these efforts may encounter a surprising obstacle: the Civil Rights Act of 1964.

The Civil Rights Act was passed to end decades of overt discrimination and disenfranchisement against blacks. It was the seminal step in moving the country toward the equality that civil rights leaders had spent years fighting to achieve, a realization of Martin Luther King Jr.’s dream that his children be judged by the content of their character, not the color of their skin. It seemed to be what the nation needed, what those fighting for equal rights wanted, and what the founding principles of the country demanded—however imperfectly they had been implemented over the years. But that was long ago.

Today’s advocates see things differently. What America needs now, they say, is not equality, but equity: a concept that trades the old notion of colorblindness for an obsessive focus on racial bean-counting and requires the race-conscious redistribution of power from whites to underrepresented minorities.

The two concepts are contradictory. Careful examination of progressive demands juxtaposed with the language of the Civil Rights Act leads to the conclusion that those demanding equity should demand the law’s repudiation.

Consider the actions of government officials during the Covid-19 pandemic. As the rollout of the vaccine unfolds, nearly half of U.S. states have stated openly that they want to prioritize the delivery of vaccines to “black and brown communities.” New York governor Andrew Cuomo chastised the federal government for not having a provision for outreach to minorities. Meantime, when civil rights leaders demanded that funding be allocated explicitly to black businesses, Oregon answered the call, establishing a fund that set aside $62 million in federal money for “black relief + resiliency.” All of this appears to violate Title VI of the Civil Rights Act, which states that no person on the ground of race, color, or national origin can be “denied the benefits of, or be subjected to, discrimination under any program or activity receiving federal financial assistance.”

Recently, New York mayor Bill de Blasio took steps to correct what he saw as systemic inequalities in the city’s selective-enrollment schools. Because the student body at these schools did not reflect the city’s racial makeup, de Blasio changed the admissions requirements from grades, attendance, and test scores to a lottery to increase the enrollment percentage of minority students. The move was heralded by equity advocates, with seemingly no regard for the provision in the Civil Rights Act that states, “desegregation shall not mean the assignment of students to public schools in order to overcome racial imbalance.”

Some “antiracists” have advocated the formation of racially segregated spaces—from black dorms and segregated graduations to the forcible reversal of gentrification in traditionally black neighborhoods—apparently unaware that Title II of the Civil Rights Act bans discrimination in public accommodations.

In the business world, progressives aim explicitly to elevate minorities at the expense of whites. Companies across the country have paid huge sums to “diversity trainers,” such as Robin DiAngelo, who ostensibly work to counteract bias in the workplace but actually further it by vilifying whites. Recently, a Coca-Cola employee leaked slides of a company diversity training session where employees were told to “be less white.” Yet Title VII of the Civil Rights Act bans attempts “to limit, segregate, or classify his employees in any way which would deprive or tend to deprive any individual of employment opportunities or otherwise adversely affect his status as an employee, because of such individual’s race, color, religion, sex, or national origin.”

Few employees are willing to risk pushing back against such treatment, and those who do can face additional discrimination. When Jodi Shaw, a former Smith College librarian, filed a complaint with the school’s institutional compliance officer over its mandatory diversity trainings and alleged hostile treatment, she was rebuffed—for a strange reason. In the words of the office of equity and inclusion representative, “The Civil Rights Act of 1964 was created to protect traditionally marginalized people.”

In fact, the Civil Rights Act protects all Americans from racial discrimination, a fact too many contemporary progressives have forgotten. How else to explain law professor Brandon Hasbrouck’s call for “vote reparations,” according to which the votes of black Americans should count twice? No matter how far-fetched Hasbrouck’s idea, it is telling that a law professor would advance a proposal so at odds with the law’s mandate that “no person shall apply any standard, practice, or procedure different from the standards, practices, or procedures applied under such law or laws to other individuals.”

Those demanding what I call “adjective justice”—social, racial, and so on—do not want equality. They justify discrimination on the basis of helping the oppressed. This approach lies at the heart of what I call progressive racism, a sort of kinder, gentler racism. Regardless of their intent, such an approach is irreconcilable with the letter of civil rights laws and the principles of the movement that led to their passage. If “antiracists” truly believe in their cause, it is only a matter of time before they decide that the Civil Rights Act of 1964 is an obstacle to the equity they seek and must be repealed for the greater good.

[Charles Love is the assistant executive director of Seeking Educational Excellence, host of The Charles Love Show, and the author of the upcoming book Race Crazy: BLM, 1619, and the Progressive Racism Movement.]

No Comments






#race riot 1619 project 1776 1964 90 million ACT Abolitionists Achievement Afghanistan African Americans Afrocentric Al Sharpton Alabama Alaska Amazon American Flag American Hero American History American Voters American racism Americans America Amy Coney Barrett Apple Asians Attorney General Keith Ellison Attorney General Letitia James Authenticity BLM Banks Barack Obama Behavior Ben Shapiro Bible Big government Bill of rights Black Americans Black Churches Black Codes Black Governor Black History Black Leader Black Lives Matter Black Millionaires Black Wall Street Black achievement Black community Black families Matter Black kids Black on Black crime Black people Black racist Black towns Black underclass Black voter suppression Black vote Blacks Black Breonna Taylo Bureau of Justice Statistics CARES Act CBS CCP CEO Elon Musk CNN CRT Calexico California Capitalism Capitol Building Carbon emissions Cartoon Catholic Cato Institute Character Charleston Charter schools Chicago Chinese Communist Party Chinese Christianity Christian City government Civil Rights Act of 1964 Civil Rights Civil War Climate Change Coal Coca-cola College Board data Color Communism Communist party Condoleezza Rice Congressional Black Caucus Congressional Budget Office Congress Conservatives Conservative Conspiracy Theories Cops Counyrt Covid-19 Create a crowd Crime Cuban people Cuba Curtis Hill DNA DNC DOJ Dave Chappelle David Boaz Decline Delta airlines Demark Democrat party Democratic Party Democratic socialism Democrats Democrat Derek Chauvin Developer Dick Gregory Disincentivizing District Attorney Diversity Doctors Documentary Donald Trump Dr. Anthony Fauci Dr. Eric M. Wallace Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Earth Day Earth Edgewater's mayor Edgewater\'s mayor Election integrity Electorate Equality Equity Eskimo FDA Facebook Fake News Farmers Fascism Fascist Fathers Federal Government Female Film Fire Fighters Flaws Food For the People Act Foundation Founding Fathers Frederick Douglass Free Market Freedm Freedom's Journal Insitute Freedom's Journal Magazine Freedoms Journal Institute Freedoms Journal Magazine Freedom Free Gangs Gasoline Gavin Newsom Gaza Strip George Floyd George Gascon George W. Bush Georgia German Global Warming Goverment Governor Cuomo Governor's race Governors Governor Grades Great Society Greater Good Greek mythology Guns Gwen Berry HBCUs Hamas Hard work Harriet Tubman Hatred Heritage Foundation High School Hillary Clinton Historically Black Colleges and Universities History Hitler Hmong Hollywood House Republican leadership House Housing Hugo Chavez Human Race Hunter Biden Hypocrisy IMDb IRS Ibram X. Kendi Identity politics Inclusion Independence Day Internal Revenue Service Inventors Isaiah Israel Jeff Bezos Jesus Christ Jews Jim Crow Jimmy Carter Joe biden John Cena John F. Kennedy John Kass John Lewis Voting Right Advancement Act John Lewis Voting Rights Advancement Act John McWhorter John Stossel Jokes Josh McDowell July 4th Jury Verdict Justice K-12 Kamala Harris Karl Marx Katrina Ken Blackwell Kingmaker Klu Klux Klan LAw LGBTQ community LGBTQ LIverals Lab Larry Elder Latinos Latinx Law enforcement Lawsuits Legacy of Slavery Liberal progressives Liberals Liberal Libertarian Los Angeles Lt. Gov. Mark Robinson Lyft MLB MLK MSNBC Mainstream media Male Manning Johnson Markets Marxists Marxist Mattel Maxine Waters Media Medicare Men Metaphore Mexican Americans Mexican Michael Brown Michael Ramirez Michelle Avan Middle East policy Military Minneapolis police department Morality Muslim N95 NAACP NAN NCAA NEA Nancy Pelosi National Urban League Nazi Neck Holds Neighborhood Watch Netflix Neutrality New Jersey Noam Chomsky Normalcy Normal Normandy North Carolina Nuclear OPEC Obergefell v. Hodges Ohio Oklahoma Olympic trial Olympics Opportunity Oracle Oscars PPolice Palestinians Pandemic Parental choice Pastor Patrick Hall Patrisse Cullors Personal freedom Platform Power plant President Donald Trump President Joe Biden President Obama Press Principles Private companies Progressive Progress Proud Race Card Race Racial hatred Racism in America Rand Paul Raphael Warnock Reform Rep. Liz Cheney Rep. Maxine Waters Republican Party Republicans Republican Rich Right to Vote Riots Risk Robert F. Kennedy Robin DiAngelo Rockerfeller Roe vs Wade Rule of Law Russians Russia SAT SEC SJW San Diego State University Scandinavia Scholarship School Choice School board Scientists Scripture Sen. Bernie Sanders Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer Sexual Harrassment Shawshank redemption Slavery Slaves Slave Snoop Dog Social Justice South Carolina Southern states Soviet Union Spacex Speaker Nancy Pelosi Speech Stacey Abrams Steve Crowder Steve Jobs Stock market Students Suffering Supporters Supremacist Supreme court Sweden Taliban Taxpayers Teachers' Union Tesla The Left The Reverend The Rich The West Thomas Jennings Thomas Sowell Tom Wolf Toymakers Trade workers Truth vs Lies Truth Tulsa 1921 Turnout Twitter US Constitution Uber Uncle Tom Underclass Underground Railroad United States flag United States Unity Vaccine Venezuela Vice President Kamala Harris Victims Victomhood Video message Vietnam Virginia Voter ID Votes Voting Rights Act Voting law Voting WGN WHO WWII WWI Walter Williams Warner Bros. Television Group Washington D.C. Water front Weakness Wealth creation Wealth White Guilt White House White People White Supremacist White Supremacy White cops White-Savior Whites White Woke Racism Woke Women WoodsonCenter Work Worldview Wuhan YouTube abnormal academia academics access activists advancement advantage adversary affirmative action air taxi alcoholic anarchy angry anti-corruption anti-semitic anti-trans antifa antiracists apartments arrested arrest assumptions athlete attacks authoritarianism authority bad decisions battle biology black clergy bonds boycott budget bill bureaucrats burglaries business owners business cancel Culture cancel cukture cancer charity cheating checks and balances chief executive city council civility civilization classroom climte college colorblind colored comedian comedy community compassion competition compliance conservative content conservative women contempt conviction corporate welfare corrupt politicians cost-free cost courage coverage criminal justice criminal crisis critical race theory culture war culture dad death penality debate decision-makers delusion democracy dictatorship differential poverty discrimination diveristy driveway economic freedom economic policy economic recovery economics economist economy education election reform elections election emotions empathy employees employee employer employment enemies energy entrance exams entrepreneurs equal results ethnicity ethnic evidence executive orders fact-checkers facts fairness faith leader faith false narrative families farms fear first amendment force gender confusion gender genocide governance government control government schools green new deal greenhouse gases groups guilty gun control gun violence handouts hate speech helpless blacks heroine hero high-income high-school curriculum homelessness homeless homicide human beings human nature hyperbole immigration impeachment individuals inequality inflation information infrastructure inheritance inner-city innovation instruction insurrection interview inventions investments jobs kids king labor force labor lawlessness liberty lies life in prison loans lock downs low income major league baseball mandates manipulated manslaughter masks medicine microaggression minimum wage misdemeanor misinformation misleading mission mixed-race couples mob violence monarchy money monument moral superiority murder name callling national anthem national debt natural immunity neopronouns normal life obfuscation officers one race opinion oppressed opt out parents patents paycheck payouts people of color people piplines podium ceremony poineers polarization police brutality police policy political exploitation politicians politics polling poverty power president prison private schools problem solving progressives pronouns prosperity protest public health public investment public policy public schools purpose qualified immunity race and culture racial inequalities racism racist nation racist white cops racist radiation radical administration ratings reactor recall reforms regulations religious liberty reparations resisting arrest respect restaurant retirement right principles riot role model rules for thee and not for me safety scholar school second amendment self-reliance sexism sexuality shootings shoplifting skin color snow social distancing social media social security socialism socialist society spending sports standards state run states stereotypes stimulus stock subjectivism subsidizing college subsidy suppression systemic racism tactic tax breaks tax the rich taxation taxes taxpayer teachers union teenagers terrorist the poor theft totalitarianism transgender woman transgender trial tribalism triillions tuition unemployment unfair unvaccinated vaccination vaccine cards venture capitalist victim culture victimology violence violent crime virology voluntary voters wages war welfare white privilege women in history