Manhattan's New DA Is Protecting Criminals Instead of Their Victims

By Charles Love

We've all heard the saying: "The road to hell is paved with good intentions." But can we still call the intentions good when we've been down the road, seen where it leads, and continue to lay faulty paving?

This is the case with the direction Alvin Bragg, Manhattan's new district attorney, is taking in his approach to crime. In a memo sent just days after being sworn in, Bragg made it clear how his office would—or would not, as the case may be—handle crime in New York City. The DA's office "will not seek a carceral sentence" except in cases of homicide, domestic violence felonies, some sex crimes and public corruption. Not only is Bragg's plan to avoid prosecuting certain crimes, but he specifically instructs prosecutors to reduce charges. "Armed robbers who use guns or other deadly weapons to stick up stores and other businesses will be prosecuted only for petty larceny, a misdemeanor, provided no victims were seriously injured and there's no 'genuine risk of physical harm' to anyone," the memo reads. Burglary, possession of a weapon (including by those with previous convictions), resisting arrest, and drug offenses should all be pursued with a charge reduction mentality.

"These policy changes not only will, in and of themselves, make us safer; they also will free up prosecutorial resources to focus on violent crime," Bragg claims.

And yet, that is a baffling sentiment coming from someone tasked to uphold the law. How does this advance the public interest?

We can believe DA Bragg's intentions are good while also not ignoring the truth: We know how this will end.

In the last two years, we've seen cities across the nation devolve into chaos. While many factors are to blame, the lack of accountability and refusal to charge perpetrators of crime is the primary reason the problem persists. While violent crime should be our primary focus—ten of the country's most populous cities set homicide records last year—ignoring other crimes causes a decline in the quality of life of citizens. Because the truth is, homicides don't happen in a vacuum. When these crimes persist, cities change. The community, the economy, the quality of life of the most vulnerable, these things begin to erode and disappear.

Take California's Prop 47, a well-intended law looking to reduce prison populations by reducing the penalty of certain crimes to a misdemeanor from a felony. The proposition passed in 2014, but in one year, many cities saw double digit increases in the crimes affected by the law. Proponents hear these stats and say it is for the greater good. They only see these crimes as crimes of property loss.

But that's not the entire story. For instance, it should be obvious what a gang member would do with an illegal firearm. And yet, in Palm Springs, a known gang member was given a citation when caught with a stolen gun because it was only valued at $625.

Fast forward a few years and Walgreens has closed several stores due to out-of-control theft. The closures represent lost tax revenue, lost jobs, and an additional burden on those who have lost the convenience of an important neighborhood business.

The question for Manhattan's new district attorney is, "Who are these changes really designed to benefit?"

Critics accuse prosecutors like Kim Foxx in Chicago, Gascon in LA, and now Bragg of being soft on crime. But what they really are is hard on citizens. When you decide on behalf of the residents of your city that having a gun pointed at them making them fear for their lives is "not a risk of harm," or that forcing them to walk through an open-air drug market to get to school is of no concern, this highlights a larger problem. Criminal justice reformers have seen injustices happen and, rightly, look for ways to improve conditions. But in their overcorrection, they are pushing us to a place where there is more concern for criminals than there is for the citizens they victimize.

Bragg told his ADAs to evaluate each person arrested and identify those who "suffer from mental illness, who are unhoused, who commit crimes of poverty, or who suffer from substance use disorders." "Charges should be brought consistent with the goal of providing services to such individuals," Bragg instructed.

Having compassion for criminals is all well and good, but in this case, the compassion seems to be reserved solely for the criminals. Shouldn't the goal of these services be targeted to law-abiding citizens?

Finally, Bragg says that we need to consider the impacts of incarceration on people convicted of crimes. This is true, but he must understand that there is also an impact to be born from not incarcerating people.

Bragg's proposals are the opposite of what someone would do if they were trying to quell crime, an issue on which the new mayor, Eric Adams, campaigned. How will Mayor Adams make the streets of New York safe when the Manhattan DA's priority is not public safety?

People need to speak up now before things get worse. The idea that we should only prosecute violent crime will only serve to continue the city's decay while we wait for repeat offenders to commit a violent act.

If you don't address criminals when they are caught with a weapon, you'll have to do so after they use it. The city would be better served if Bragg took a lesson from the other cities whose mayors are waking up to the realization that ignoring crime, of all kinds, emboldens criminals and makes cities less safe.

[Charles Love is the executive director of Seeking Educational Excellence, host of The Charles Love Show, and the author of Race Crazy: BLM, 1619, and the Progressive Racism Movement.]

No Comments


Recent

Archive

 2022

Categories

Tags

Virginia #BLM #BoycottDisney #Hatecrimehoax #Joe Rogan #KingdomsinKonflict #RoevsWade #Ukraine #freedomsjournalmagazine #globalwarming #hunterbiden #prolife #race riot #theslap #trans #whitereplacementtheory 1619 project 1776 1964 1972 2024 2nd Amendment 8.5% 90 million ACT AMA Abbot Laboratories Abolitionists Academy Awards Achievement Afghanistan African American History Museum African Americans Afrocentric Airlines Airplanes Al Sharpton Alabama Alaska Alexandra Ocasio-Cortez All Lives Matter Alvin Bragg Amazon American Flag American Hero American History American Medical Association American Values American Voters American racism Americans America Amy Coney Barrett Andrew Yang Apple Asians Attorney General Keith Ellison Attorney General Letitia James Aubrey Shines Authenticity BLM Baby formula Babylon Bee Background checks Ballot Harvesting Baltimore Banks Barack Obama Barnes Behavior Belguim Ben Shapiro Bible Biden Administration Big Tech Big government Bill of rights Birthday Black Americans Black America Black Churches Black Coaches Black Codes Black Democrats Black Governor Black History Black Leader Black Lives Matter Black Millionaires Black Progress Black Republicans Black Wall Street Black achievement Black community Black families Matter Black kids Black liberal Democrats Black on Black crime Black people Black racist Black resilience Black towns Black underclass Black voter suppression Black vote Black women Blacks Black Blue states Books Booster Breonna Taylo Brian Flores Build Back Better bill Build Back Better Bureau of Justice Statistics CARES Act CBS CCP CDC CEO Bob Chapek CEO Elon Musk CNN CRT Calexico California Candace Owens Capitalism Capitol Building Carbon emissions Cartoon Catholic Cato Institute Center Character Charles Love Charleston Charlie Brown Charlottesville Charter schools Chicago Chicken Children China Chinese Communist Party Chinese Choke point Chris Rock Christian values Christianity Christian Christmas story Christopher Rufo Church City government Civil Rights Act of 1964 Civil Rights Civil War Class room Climate Change Clinical trials Coal Coca-cola Colgan Air crash Collective College Board data Color Columnists Communism Communist party Community center Commuters Condoleezza Rice Confederate monument Congressional Black Caucus Congressional Budget Office Congress Conservatives Conservative Conspiracy Theories Contractor Cops Counyrt Covid-19 Create a crowd Crime prevention Crime Criminality Crispus Attucks Critical Legal Theory Crowdfunding Cuban people Cuba Curtis Hill DEI DNA DNC DOJ Daily Wire Darrell Brooks Dave Chappelle David Boaz David Henderson Dear Larry Death rates Deaths Death Debt Decline Defense Department Deficit Delta airlines Delta Demark Democrat party Democratic Party Democratic socialism Democrats Democrat Dennis Prager Department of Justice Derek Chauvin Developer Dick Gregory Dinner Disabled Discovery Institute Disincentivizing District Attorney Diversity Doctors Documentary Dollar Don Lemmon Donald Trump Dr. Ada Fisher Dr. Anthony Fauci Dr. Eric M. Wallace Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Dr. Martin Luther King Dr. Stephen Meyer Drivers Driving while black EBLM Earth Day Earth Easter Edgewater's mayor Edgewater\'s mayor Egalitarian Election integrity Electorate Equality Equity Eskimo Europe Exodus FBI FDA FEMA Facebook Fackcheck.org Fake News Farmers Fascism Fascist Fathers Federal Emergency Management Act Federal Government Federal Reserve Females Female Film Fire Fighters Flaws Florida Flying Food For the People Act Foundation Founding Fathers Frederick Douglass Free Market Free Speech Freedm Freedom to Cheat Act Freedom to Vote Act Freedom's Journal Insitute Freedom's Journal Magazine Freedom\'s Journal Insitute Freedoms Journal Institute Freedoms Journal Magazine Freedom Free GALECA GMO GOP Gangs Gasoline Gavin Newsom Gay Pride Gay Gaza Strip General Managers George Floyd George Gascon George W. Bush George Wallace Georgia Germany German Glenn Youngkin Global Warming Globalist Gov. Eric Holcomb Gov. Ron DeSantis Goverment Government spending Governor Cuomo Governor's race Governors Governor Grades Grand Jury Great Society Greater Good Greedy Greek mythology Guns Gwen Berry HBCUs Hamas Hard work Harriet Tubman Harry Reid Hate crime Haters Hatred Hebrew scriptures Heritage Foundation High School Hillary Clinton Historical truth Historically Black Colleges and Universities History Channel History Hitler Hmong Hollywood Holocaust Homes Hong Kong Hosea House Republican leadership House Housing Hugo Chavez Human Race Human trafficking Hunter Biden Hypocrisy Hysteria IMDb IRS Ian Rowe Ibram X. Kendi Identity politics Immigrants Inclusion Independence Day Indiana Individual responsibility Internal Revenue Service Inventors Iran Iraq war Isaiah Islamic State Israel Jack Kemp James Madison James Monroe January 6 Jeff Bezos Jesus Christ Jesus Jews Jim Crow Jimmy Carter Job Joe Rogan Joe biden John Cena John F. Kennedy John Kass John Lewis Voting Right Advancement Act John Lewis Voting Rights Act John Lewis Voting Rights Advancement Act John McWhorter John Stossel Jokes Josh McDowell Joy Reid Judge Janice Rogers Brown July 4th Jurisprudence Jury Verdict Jussie Smollett Justice Alito Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson Justice Thomas Justice K-12 Kamala Harris Karl Marx Katrina Kay Coles James Ken Blackwell Kenosha Kevin McGary Kevin McGray Kim Potter Kingdoms in Konflict Kingmaker Klaus Schwab Klu Klux Klan Kyle Rittenhouse LAw LGBTQ community LGBTQ LIverals Lab Larry Elder Latinos Latinx Law enforcement Lawsuits Leak Left Legacy of Slavery Legal Protection Lia Thomas Liberal Democrats Liberal progressives Liberals Liberal Libertarian Life Littlejohn Lockdown Looters Los Angeles Times Los Angeles Louisiana Lt. Gov. Mark Robinson Lucy Lyft Lynching MAP MLB MLK MSM MSNBC Mainstream media Malcolm X Male Manning Johnson Margret Sanger Markets Marxists Marxist Mask mandates Matt Walsh Mattel Maxine Waters Media Medicare Men Meritocracy Metaphore Mexican Americans Mexican Michael Brown Michael Ramirez Michelle Avan Michigan Mickey Mouse Middle East policy Midrash Military Millions Minneapolis police department Mishnah Mocking Morality Moving Murders Muslim minority Muslim N-word N95 NAACP NAN NATO NBA NCAA NEA NFL coaches Nancy Pelosi Nat Turner National Urban League Nazis Nazi Neck Holds Neighborhood Watch Netflix Neutrality New Jersey New York City New York Times New biological information Noam Chomsky Normalcy Normal Normandy North Carolina North Korea Nuclear Nutrition O block OPEC Obamacare Obergefell v. Hodges Ohio Oil prices Oklahoma Olympic trial Olympics Omicon Opportunity Oracle Organic food Oscars PPolice Palestinians Pandemic Panthers Parag Agrawal Parental choice Parental rights Parks Passover Pastor Corey Brooks Pastor Patrick Hall Patrisse Cullors Peanuts Pennsylvania Pentagon Perish Perjury Personal Responsibility Personal freedom Pharmaceutical companies Photo ID Pilgrims Pilots Plants Platform Podcast Political parties Pork Post-Civil Rights Era Power plant Pregnant President Donald Trump President Joe Biden President Obama Press Prime Minister Justin Trudeau Principles Private Property Private companies Pro-choice Proces Progressive Progress Project HOOD Proud Proverbs Psalm 19 Public Property Public vs Private ROOFTOP Race Card Race-based Race Racial hatred Racism in America Radical Progressives Ranchers Rand Paul Randi Weingarten Raphael Warnock Raynard Jackson Rebuilt Red Sea Red States Red Wave Reform Refugees Rent Control Renters Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez Rep. Liz Cheney Rep. Maxine Waters Repent Republican Party Republicans Republican Respite Responsible Government Revitalization Rich Right Wing Right to Vote Right Riots Risk Robert F. Kennedy Robin DiAngelo Rockerfeller Roe vs Wade Roland Martin Rule of Law Russian invasion Russians Russia SAT SCOTUS SEC SJW Sacramento Bee Salvation Army San Diego State University San Francisco Sayyid Ali Khamenei Scandinavia Scholarship School Choice School board Science Scientists Scripture Seattle Seder Segregation Sen. Bernie Sanders Sen. Rand Paul Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer Serge Kovaleski Sexual Harrassment Sex Shawshank redemption Shut downs Shutdowns Skillsocracy Skip Bayless Slap Slavery Slaves Slave Snoop Dog Social Justice Soldiers South Carolina Southern states Soviet Union Spacex Speaker Nancy Pelosi Speech Spotify Stacey Abrams State of the Union States rights Statesman Steve Crowder Steve Jobs Steven Kerr Stock market Stores Students Suffering Supporters Supremacist Supreme court Sweden TERFs Taiwan Taliban Talmud Tawana Brawley Taxpayers Teachers' Union Teachers Teaching Tesla The Left The Onion The Reverend The Rich The State The Universe is fine tuned for life The West The Woke Zone Thomas Jennings Thomas Sowell Title-42 Tom Wolf Toymakers Trade workers Traffic Training Transgenderism Truck Drivers Truth vs Lies Truth Tulsa 1921 Turnout Tuskegee airmen Twitter U.S. Constitution U.S. Supreme Court US Constitution USA Uber Ukraine Uncle Tom Underclass Underground Railroad Unforgiveness Unionized monopolies United Nations United States Supreme Court United States flag United States Unity Universal basic income Universe has a beginning Urban areas Utopian Uyghurs Vaccine Venezuela Vice President Kamala Harris Victimhood Victims Victomhood Video message Vietnam Virginia Virus Vitriol Vladimir Putin Voter Fraud Voter ID Votes Voting Rights Act Voting law Voting WGN WHO WIC WWII WWI Walt Disney Company Walter Williams Warner Bros. Television Group Washington D.C. Washington Post Water front Weakness Wealth creation Wealth Weapons Welfare state White Christians White Guilt White House White People White Supremacist White Supremacy White cops White-Savior Whiteness Whites White Whoopi Goldberg Wikipedia Will Smith Winsome Sears Wisconsin Wke Woke Racism Woke Women's rights Women's sports Women\'s sports Womens sports Women Wonderful life WoodsonCenter Work World Economic Forum World Health Orhanization Worldview Write male Wuhan YouTube abnormal abortion absentee ballots academia academics access acting white activists advancement advantage adversary advocate affirmative action agency air taxi alcoholic anarchy angry anti-corruption anti-establishment anti-semitic anti-trans antifa antiracists apartments apologize arrested arrest assimilation assumptions athlete attacks authoritarianism authority automatic tax filing babies bad decisions bathroom battle bigotry biological brainwashing biological female biological men biology black clergy black face of white supremacy blacklisted bonds boycott broadband budget bill bureaucrats burglaries business owners business cancel Culture cancel cukture cancer censors charge reduction charity cheating checks and balances chief executive city council civil unrest civility civilization classroom clean climte college colorblind colored comedian comedy commons community compassion competition compliance confiscation congressional maps consequences conservative content conservative principles conservative women construction contempt conviction corporate greed corporate welfare corrupt politicians cost of living cost-free cost courage coverage crime free criminal justice criminals criminal crisis critical race theory cultual marxism culture war culture dad death penality debate decision-makers delusion democracy dictatorship differential poverty discipleship discrimination disenfranchised diveristy double-speak driveway drugs economic freedom economic ignorance economic policy economic recovery economics economic economist economy editing education election reform elections election elitists emotions empathy employees employee employer employment empowerment encyclopedias enemies energy independence energy entrance exams entrepreneurs environment equal results equal rights ethnicity ethnic eugenics evidence excess profits executive orders experts expressive individualism fact-checkers facts fairness faith leader faith false narratives false narrative families far left farms fear federal judge federal law federalizing filibuster first amendment first black female followers force foreign policy fossil fuels gas gender confusion gender identity gender genetic modification genocide gerrymander giving goats governance government control government protection government schools green new deal greenhouse gases groups guilty gun bans gun control gun violence handouts hate speech helpless blacks heroine hero high-income high-school curriculum home equity home theft homelessness homeless homicides homicide homocide hospitalization hospital hours human beings human nature hyperbole illegal immigrants illegal votes immigration impact impeachment incentive individuals inequality inflation information infrastructure inheritance inner-city innocent blood innocent innovation instruction insurrection interview inventions investments jobs journalism kids king labor force labor landlords laptop computer lawlessness leadership left-wing legal votes liar liberty licensed lies life in prison limited government loans lock downs low income lowering standards maintenance major league baseball mandates manipulated manslaughter masks mass incarceration mass shootings mass-incarceration medicine microaggression middle school military budget minimum wage minority misdemeanor misinformation misleading mission mixed-race couples mob violence monarchy money monument moral fabric moral superiority moral murder name callling national anthem national debt natural immunity neopronouns nonprofits normal life nurses obfuscation officers oil industry omicron one race opinion oppressed oppression oppressors vs. oppressed opt out out-migration out-of-control theft outcast outdoors pansexual parents partisan patents paycheck payouts pedophilia people of color people pipeline piplines platforms podium ceremony poineers polarization police brutality police policy political exploitation political left political rhetoric politicians politics polling poor population growth poverty power preferences president price gouging prison private schools problem solving profiling progressives prolife pronouns prosperity protection protest public health public investment public policy public schools purpose qualified immunity race and culture race-baiting racial bias racial equality racial inequalities racial resentment racism racist nation racist white cops racists racist radiation radical administration ratings reactor recall reforms regulations religious liberty renewables reparations reporter resisting arrest respect restaurant retirement ridicule right principles right-wing riot role model rules for thee and not for me rules safety satire scholar school second amendment self defense self-reliance semiautomatic rifle sexes sexism sexual orientation sexuality sheep shootings shoplifting shortage skin color slave labor snow social distancing social media social security socialism socialist societal inequalities society solar spending sports events sports standards state law state legislatures state run states stereotypes stimulus stock subjectivism subsidizing college subsidy supply and demand suppression swing voters systemic racism tactic talent tax breaks tax payments tax the rich taxation taxes taxpayer teachers union teenagers terrorist the Forward Party the Gospels the Homeless the Return of the God Hypothesis the least of these the poor theft tortured totalitarianism transgender woman transgender trial tribalism triillions tuition unemployment unfair union unpopular unvaccinated vaccination vaccine cards venture capitalist victim culture victimology violence crime violence violent crime virology virtue voluntary voters wages war welfare white privilege wind women in history