The Circular Logic of Systemic Racism

By Ben Shapiro 

Last week, ex-police officer Derek Chauvin was convicted of second-degree murder, third-degree murder and second-degree manslaughter. The evidence on the murder charges was weak; the evidence on manslaughter was significantly stronger. Still, the jury took only 10 hours and zero questions to come to its conclusion: guilty on all counts.

In and of itself, the Chauvin case never should have been a national news story. After all, an average of three suspects are shot by police every day in the United States, and thousands of homicides that have nothing whatsoever to do with the police take place in the United States every year. Theoretically, national news stories should be indicative of profound national problems, not man-bites-dog statistical rarities.

But, of course, that was the entire point of elevating the George Floyd story to national attention: to declare it indicative of a deeper rot at the core of America. Thus, Chauvin was convicted not of his individual criminal activity but of a charge that was never even brought against him: the charge of racism. As Minnesota Attorney General Keith Ellison admitted, there was no evidence whatsoever that Chauvin was a racist, or that his killing of George Floyd was motivated by race. "We don't have any evidence that Derek Chauvin factored in George Floyd's race as he did what he did," Ellison ruefully told incredulous "60 Minutes" host Scott Pelley. And Pelley, speaking for the entire establishment media -- a left-wing bubble thoroughly invested in the narrative of systemic American racism -- responded, "The whole world sees this as a white officer killing a black man because he is black."

Pelley isn't wrong. In the end, evidence for systemic racism is utterly unnecessary. Systemic racism requires no evidence of intent, either individual or systemic. It requires only evidence of disparate outcome by race. Which is why Ellison explained that even though he couldn't charge Chauvin with a hate crime, he could charge the entire system with racism in the Chauvin case: "In order for us to stop and pay serious attention to this case and be outraged by it, it's not necessary that Derek Chauvin had a specific racial intent to harm George Floyd. ... (P)eople of color, Black people, end up with harsh treatment from law enforcement. And other folks doing the exact same thing just don't."

Now, statistically speaking, this is simply untrue. In late 2020, the Bureau of Justice Statistics released a report that found no statistically significant difference by race between criminal activity and arrest -- in other words, you get arrested in America if you are reported to have committed a crime, no matter your race. Multiple studies, from Harvard's Roland Fryer to professor Peter Moskos of John Jay College of Criminal Justice at City University New York, show that police officers are less likely to kill black Americans than white Americans in similar circumstances.

But to ask for evidence of systemic racism beyond mere inequality of outcome is to be complicit in systemic racism, according to the circular logic of systemic racism. Any incident of white-cop-on-black-suspect violence must be chalked up to the racist system; the evidence of the racist system is the presence of such violence in the first place; to deny that race lies at the root of such incidents makes you a cog in the racist system. The circular logic, protected by an enormous so-called Kafka trap -- in which protestations of innocence are treated as proof of guilt -- means that systemic racism is subject to no falsification.

And that's precisely the point. Systemic racism is a fundamentalist religious belief. It posits original sin; it posits saints and prophets; it posits its own malevolent god of the gaps. Most of all, it persecutes heretics in the name of a supposedly higher good. To be saved is to declare fealty to radical racial polarization; to be damned is to deny such fealty.

[Ben Shapiro, 36, is a graduate of UCLA and Harvard Law School, host of "The Ben Shapiro Show" and editor-in-chief of DailyWire.com. He is the author of the New York Times bestsellers "How to Destroy America in Three Easy Steps," "The Right Side of History" and "Bullies." To find out more about Ben Shapiro and read features by other Creators Syndicate writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators Syndicate website at www.creators.com.]
COPYRIGHT 2021 CREATORS.COM

Related Posts

2 Comments


Redwolf - April 28th, 2021 at 8:51am

Well if denying systemic racism damns me in the eyes of liberals then so be it. As far as I'm concerned if liberals accuse me of some great sin then I figure I must be doing something right.

Chris Carmouche - April 28th, 2021 at 10:09am

It’s so sad that Ben Shapiro is on the wrong side of this issue.

Recent

Archive

 2021

Categories

Tags

1776 1964 90 million ACT Abolitionists African Americans Al Sharpton Alabama American Voters America Amy Coney Barrett Asians Attorney General Keith Ellison BLM Behavior Bible Bill of rights Black Americans Black Codes Black History Black Leader Black Lives Matter Black Millionaires Black achievement Black community Black families Matter Black kids Black people Black vote Blacks Breonna Taylo Bureau of Justice Statistics CARES Act CBS CNN California Capitalism Capitol Building Carbon emissions Cato Institute Christianity City government Civil Rights Civil War Climate Change Coca-cola College Board data Condoleezza Rice Congressional Black Caucus Congressional Budget Office Conservatives Conservative Conspiracy Theories Cops Covid-19 Create a crowd Crime Cuba DNA David Boaz Delta airlines Democrat party Democratic Party Democratic socialism Democrats Democrat Derek Chauvin Dick Gregory Diversity Documentary Donald Trump Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Earth Day Election integrity Equality Equity Facebook Fake News Fascism Fascist Film Fire Fighters Foundation Founding Fathers Free Market Freedm Freedom's Journal Insitute Freedom's Journal Magazine Freedoms Journal Institute Freedoms Journal Magazine Freedom George Floyd George W. Bush Georgia Global Warming Governors Grades HBCUs Harriet Tubman Hatred Heritage Foundation High School Hillary Clinton Historically Black Colleges and Universities History Hitler Hollywood House Hugo Chavez Hypocrisy IMDb Identity politics Inclusion Inventors Israel Jim Crow Jimmy Carter Joe biden John Kass Jokes Jury Verdict Justice Kamala Harris Karl Marx Katrina Kingmaker Klu Klux Klan LAw LGBTQ LIverals Larry Elder Latinos Law enforcement Lawsuits Legacy of Slavery Liberal progressives Liberals Liberal Libertarian Lt. Gov. Mark Robinson MLB MLK MSNBC Mainstream media Marxist Maxine Waters Media Metaphore Michael Brown Middle East policy Minneapolis police department Morality NAACP NAN Nancy Pelosi Nazi Neck Holds Noam Chomsky Normal North Carolina Nuclear Obergefell v. Hodges Oracle Oscars PPolice Pastor Patrisse Cullors Personal freedom Power plant President Donald Trump President Joe Biden President Obama Press Progressive Race Card Race Racism in America Raphael Warnock Rep. Maxine Waters Republican Party Republicans Republican Rich Right to Vote Riots Roe vs Wade Russia SAT SJW Scandinavia School Choice Shawshank redemption Slavery Social Justice Soviet Union Speech Stacey Abrams Steve Crowder Stock market Students Supporters Supremacist Sweden Taxpayers Teachers' Union Tesla The Reverend Thomas Jennings Thomas Sowell Tom Wolf Trade workers Truth vs Lies Truth Twitter US Constitution Uncle Tom Underground Railroad Unity Vaccine Venezuela Voter ID Voting Rights Act Voting law WGN Walter Williams Warner Bros. Television Group Washington D.C. Wealth creation White House White People White Supremacist White cops White-Savior Whites Woke Work YouTube abnormal academia activists advancement affirmative action angry anti-semitic antifa antiracists arrested arrest biology boycott business owners cancer civility college comedian compliance conservative women contempt conviction coverage criminal justice critical race theory culture war death penality debate delusion democracy discrimination diveristy driveway economic recovery economics economist economy education election reform elections employee employer entrance exams evidence executive orders faith leader farms first amendment force gender greenhouse gases guilty hate speech helpless blacks heroine hero homicide hyperbole immigration impeachment inequality infrastructure inheritance inner-city innovation investments jobs kids lies life in prison loans lock downs major league baseball mandates manslaughter masks microaggression minimum wage mob violence money monument moral superiority murder name callling neopronouns officers oppressed opt out patents paycheck payouts people of color poineers police brutality police political exploitation politicians politics poverty power prison progressives public investment qualified immunity race and culture racism racist nation racist white cops racist radiation radical administration ratings reactor regulations reparations resisting arrest restaurant retirement riot rules for thee and not for me scholar sexism sexuality skin color snow social distancing social media social security socialism spending stereotypes subjectivism subsidizing college subsidy systemic racism taxes taxpayer teenagers trial tribalism triillions tuition unemployment victim culture victimology violence wages welfare white privilege women in history