The Fight Over Identity

By Ben Shapiro

America has been wrecked on the shoals of identity.

Identity politics has been characterized casually as a form of tribalism: Americans grouping themselves according to biological or sexual characteristics, in opposition to other groups associated by biological or sexual characteristics. There is certainly truth to the idea that such tribalism has damaged America in extraordinary ways -- that tribalism acts as the sort of factionalism the Founding Fathers feared, tearing Americans from one another and forcing them into polarized units to compete against others in a battle over control.

But there is another form of identity politics even more sinister than the sort of tribalism we see so openly today, a form that focuses less on politics than on identity: the redefinition of identity itself.

For thousands of years, human beings established their identities by learning how to adapt to the systems in which they lived, gradually changing those systems for the better after determining the flaws within them. This is how parents traditionally civilized children -- by adapting them to their civilization.

But as Carl Trueman explains in his masterful book "The Rise and Triumph of the Modern Self," the post-Enlightenment era tore away at the core assumption of such notions of identity. Instead of adapting ourselves to the institutions around us and forming our identity within those institutions, human beings in the West began to locate their identity within -- to look to their own sense of authenticity as the guide to fulfillment. In this view, identity was not formed in tandem with civilization but in opposition to it. Only by rebelling against the strictures of a surrounding society, by breaking free of convention, could individuals finally achieve fulfillment.

Furthermore, fulfillment would require not merely an interior sense of identity but a sense of identity cheered and celebrated by everyone else. After all, human beings still feel the need for acceptance. To reject someone else's authentic sense of self-identification, therefore, becomes an act of emotional violence.

We have now taken this view to its logical endpoint: total subjectivism, requiring the destruction of any and all conflicting viewpoints or data. Take, for example, a recent New York Times piece applauding the rise of so-called neopronouns. With the explosion of new subjective identities -- and the demand that others endorse them -- has come a wave of new pronouns. We are no longer talking about biological males demanding that others identify them as "she/her" in contravention of all available objective science. We are talking about people insisting that others call them "kitten/kittenself" or "vamp/vampself." Now, some might find this to be frivolous nonsense disconnected from any true sense of identity. But as The New York Times blithely notes, "what's the difference between an aesthetic and an identity anyway?"

This is saying the quiet part out loud. For decades, those who insist that identity is constructed in opposition to society's rules -- rules that must be eliminated in order to achieve human flourishing -- have suggested that authentic identity is more than mere aesthetics. But now The Times has given away the show: When you construct identity as a tabula rasa, seeing all history and science as obstacles to happiness, identity quickly flattens into aesthetics. And we are all expected to agree with your sense of aesthetics. (Unless, as The Times notes, you identify as "BLM" or other terms related to Black Lives Matter. In that case, you are encroaching on longstanding areas of sensitivity and must atone.)

When identity becomes pure aesthetics, society completely atomizes. No free society can be rooted in utter subjectivity -- someone must enforce silence from the top, bar dissenters and punish those who insist on objective data. And that's precisely what we are seeing from an authoritarian left: an authoritarian left that arrived with the promise of fulfillment and authenticity and has instead delivered emptiness and aesthetic pretension, enforced by institutional fiat.

[Ben Shapiro, 36, is a graduate of UCLA and Harvard Law School, host of "The Ben Shapiro Show" and editor-in-chief of DailyWire.com. He is the author of the New York Times bestsellers "How to Destroy America in Three Easy Steps," "The Right Side of History" and "Bullies." To find out more about Ben Shapiro and read features by other Creators Syndicate writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators Syndicate website at www.creators.com.]

COPYRIGHT 2021 CREATORS.COM

Related Posts

1 Comment


Charles Walkup Jr - April 14th, 2021 at 9:38am

As one who has dealt with same-sex attraction (never gay, a designation of sexual abnormality, not an Identity), if we don't know that our true identity is God's beloved child, then this is what we are left with. We give the world/Satan (the father of lies) to tell us who we are. And without God as our Father offering forgiveness for our sins, the guilt that still plagues us has no means to be resolved.

Recent

Archive

 2021

Categories

Tags

1776 1964 90 million ACT Abolitionists African Americans Al Sharpton Alabama American Voters America Amy Coney Barrett Asians Attorney General Keith Ellison BLM Behavior Bible Bill of rights Black Americans Black Codes Black History Black Leader Black Lives Matter Black Millionaires Black achievement Black community Black families Matter Black kids Black people Black vote Blacks Breonna Taylo Bureau of Justice Statistics CARES Act CBS CNN California Capitalism Capitol Building Carbon emissions Cato Institute Christianity City government Civil Rights Civil War Climate Change Coca-cola College Board data Condoleezza Rice Congressional Black Caucus Congressional Budget Office Conservatives Conservative Conspiracy Theories Cops Covid-19 Create a crowd Crime Cuba DNA David Boaz Delta airlines Democrat party Democratic Party Democratic socialism Democrats Democrat Derek Chauvin Dick Gregory Diversity Documentary Donald Trump Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Earth Day Election integrity Equality Equity Facebook Fake News Fascism Fascist Film Fire Fighters Foundation Founding Fathers Free Market Freedm Freedom's Journal Insitute Freedom's Journal Magazine Freedoms Journal Institute Freedoms Journal Magazine Freedom George Floyd George W. Bush Georgia Global Warming Governors Grades HBCUs Harriet Tubman Hatred Heritage Foundation High School Hillary Clinton Historically Black Colleges and Universities History Hitler Hollywood House Hugo Chavez Hypocrisy IMDb Identity politics Inclusion Inventors Israel Jim Crow Jimmy Carter Joe biden John Kass Jokes Jury Verdict Justice Kamala Harris Karl Marx Katrina Kingmaker Klu Klux Klan LAw LGBTQ LIverals Larry Elder Latinos Law enforcement Lawsuits Legacy of Slavery Liberal progressives Liberals Liberal Libertarian Lt. Gov. Mark Robinson MLB MLK MSNBC Mainstream media Marxist Maxine Waters Media Metaphore Michael Brown Middle East policy Minneapolis police department Morality NAACP NAN Nancy Pelosi Nazi Neck Holds Noam Chomsky Normal North Carolina Nuclear Obergefell v. Hodges Oracle Oscars PPolice Pastor Patrisse Cullors Personal freedom Power plant President Donald Trump President Joe Biden President Obama Press Progressive Race Card Race Racism in America Raphael Warnock Rep. Maxine Waters Republican Party Republicans Republican Rich Right to Vote Riots Roe vs Wade Russia SAT SJW Scandinavia School Choice Shawshank redemption Slavery Social Justice Soviet Union Speech Stacey Abrams Steve Crowder Stock market Students Supporters Supremacist Sweden Taxpayers Teachers' Union Tesla The Reverend Thomas Jennings Thomas Sowell Tom Wolf Trade workers Truth vs Lies Truth Twitter US Constitution Uncle Tom Underground Railroad Unity Vaccine Venezuela Voter ID Voting Rights Act Voting law WGN Walter Williams Warner Bros. Television Group Washington D.C. Wealth creation White House White People White Supremacist White cops White-Savior Whites Woke Work YouTube abnormal academia activists advancement affirmative action angry anti-semitic antifa antiracists arrested arrest biology boycott business owners cancer civility college comedian compliance conservative women contempt conviction coverage criminal justice critical race theory culture war death penality debate delusion democracy discrimination diveristy driveway economic recovery economics economist economy education election reform elections employee employer entrance exams evidence executive orders faith leader farms first amendment force gender greenhouse gases guilty hate speech helpless blacks heroine hero homicide hyperbole immigration impeachment inequality infrastructure inheritance inner-city innovation investments jobs kids lies life in prison loans lock downs major league baseball mandates manslaughter masks microaggression minimum wage mob violence money monument moral superiority murder name callling neopronouns officers oppressed opt out patents paycheck payouts people of color poineers police brutality police political exploitation politicians politics poverty power prison progressives public investment qualified immunity race and culture racism racist nation racist white cops racist radiation radical administration ratings reactor regulations reparations resisting arrest restaurant retirement riot rules for thee and not for me scholar sexism sexuality skin color snow social distancing social media social security socialism spending stereotypes subjectivism subsidizing college subsidy systemic racism taxes taxpayer teenagers trial tribalism triillions tuition unemployment victim culture victimology violence wages welfare white privilege women in history